The first bite reminded me of that oval-shaped peanut butter eggs covered with waxy chocolate that have been
standard in Easter baskets for the past decade.
The defining
characteristic of a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup is how well the chocolate
and peanut butter blend in your mouth. It's why generic
versions are never quite as satisfying -- they can't quite approximate
the balance of a Reese's.
But with the dark chocolate, you get a much greater contrast between the peanut butter and chocolate. The chocolate is the candy equivalent of semi-sweet chocolate chips you would use in baking. The peanut butter is saltier and even has a bit of roasted flavor. It tastes less sweet than the original -- almost like creamy natural peanut butter that has a bit of a grainy texture.
The end result is a slightly softer peanut butter cup that, while interesting, only serves to reinforce what you might have expected -- you're better off with the original.
Showing 1-2 of 2
I had these years ago when they first came out (early 2000s). They are not near as good as they were then. There was 'more' of the whole thing, and better PB and dark chocolate.
Sigh.
I haven't tried these yet but no PB cup should ever be soft.. the first step in eating a PB cup is sticking it in the freezer for a little bit.