Back in my Bannister Mall days (yes, I'm old), I loved 1 Potato 2. They served huge baked potatoes with unhealthy toppings. Delicious.
Onion rings. I regret them every single time and yet I cannot stop eating them.
I loved the Kona Kai!
I like an Italian sub with the works. D'Bronx has great ones (I also like their Vegetarian sub and the Irv's Favorite Sandwich at the Crown Center location).
Art of Pizza makes a good classic Italian cold sub, but it's about twice as large as it needs to be. Twenty 20 in the Crossroads has a good one as well.
I desperately miss the cheesecake they used to have at New York Bakery & Deli. They stopped offering it quite a while before they closed, though, so it's been years.
A bacon, egg and cheese biscuit from Burger King. But there were extenuating circumstances.
Re: “Which American beer should everyone be drinking this July 4?”
I have a good supply of Boulevard Pilsner for people who are afraid of "fancy" beers and some Tank 7 for myself.