Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Inspirational Business Writing Hits A New Low with Studies in Crap and Pro-Sumer Power!

Posted by Alan Scherstuhl on Tue, Jun 16, 2009 at 6:00 AM

Your Crap

Archivist brings you the finest in forgotten and bewildering crap

culled from area basements, thrift stores, estate sales and flea

markets. I do this for one reason: Knowledge is power.

Pro-Sumer Power! How to Create Wealth by Spending Smarter, Not

Cheaper

click to enlarge prosumerccover.jpg

Author:

Bill Quain, PhD

Publisher:

INTI Publishing &

Resource Books, Tampa, Florida

Date:

2000

Discovered

at: 2nd

Chance Thrift, Wornall Road

The

Cover Promises: Back

before the tech bubble burst, all you had to do to get rich was just

wave your Visa in front of a computer.

Representative

Quote: "The word

pro-sumer is a

combination of the words producer

and consumer. Producers

make money. Consumers spend money. Pro-sumers make money while they

spend." (page 9).

In all

of Pro-Sumer Power!,

the first book I've ever wanted to punch in the crotch, there is but

one flicker of genuine inspiration, and that's right there in the

title. Apparently, we're now free to swap prefixes and root-words as

we please. After pro-suming, who's up for a ride on a circum-cycle

with an para-hobo?

Other

than that, this merely demonstrates how insulting the

you-deserve-wealth-because-you're-special genre has come to be. More

full of nothing than the deepest reaches of space, Pro-Sumer

Power! disguises its emptiness

behind asinine parables, laughable charts, self-help lies, a story

about Lassie, a

discussion of iMac commercials, and countless exclamations of the

beauty of an idea it never gets around to defining.


"I

call it 'pro-suming.' And it's a proven way whereby you can

produce and consume at the same time!

No, that wasn't a misprint. Just to make sure your eyes aren't

playing tricks on you, I'll write that statement in all capital

letters:
THERE IS A WAY YOU

CAN PRODUCE AND CONSUME AT THE SAME TIME!"

In all

108 pages, Quain never explains how someone

can produce and consume at the same time. (I think it has something

to do with eating on the toilet.)

Instead,

Quain strings along the gullible by doling out one bit of pro-sumer

philosophy for every ten interruptions. He'll loosely introduce a

concept, explaining that even purchasing discounted goods isn't good enough for a pro-sumer since "You can't 'save' money by

consuming, because money is going out, not coming in." Then, instead of elaborating, he'll quote a Family

Circus or ask "Do you want

to be the gorilla or the banana?"

The gorilla

question deserves exploration. Quain writes,

"The

simple truth is that consumers are the bananas and the stores are the

gorillas. Gorillas need bananas to survive. So the gorillas come up

with all kinds of tricks and schemes (they call it marketing) to

attract more bananas. Offering deep discounts is their favorite

'trick.' And the bananas fall for it every time. They line up and get

eaten by the gorillas, who get fatter and fatter and happier and

happier."

This raises some

concerns.

  1. What stores

    eat their customers?

  2. What do

    gorillas have that bananas want?

  3. How

    exactly does one market to

    bananas?

  4. Can

    gorillas produce and consume at the same time?

In chapter two,

Quain instructs us to "THINK DIFFERENT" and solve this maze:

(This

is meant to illustrate how we should THINK DIFFERENT, but the answer

-- go around -- is

marked right there on the maze itself.)

Also, nobody's ever

lost money on the Internet!

prosumerchart_02.jpg

To recap:

  • THINK

    DIFFERENT.

  • Cleverly circumvent obstacles by

    following a path someone has marked for you.

  • Never spend

    your money because by spending it you have less money not to spend.

  • Pad your note

    card's worth of ideas out into a full book by any means necessary.

Shocking Detail:

Thirty-seven pages

before the end, Quain is still trying to sell you this book:

"What

if I could show you a way to have your cake and eat it too? A way not

only to 'save' money, but to earn money, while you save time? Would

that be a revolutionary concept worth learning about?"

Then, just one page

away, comes something of an answer. Turns out that pro-sumers

practice something "e-ferral" commerce, which Quain defines as "a

combination of a 50 year-old proven industry called Referral

Commerce, combined with the speed and efficiency of e-commerce."

Eight

pages, two anecdotes, and a description of a Mercedes commercial

later, he makes his pitch: referrals, exponential growth, gulling

your friends into buying vitamin supplements-- ah, shit, this is

Amway!

[Your Crap

Archivist shakes his fist.]

Actually,

it's Quixtar, the

multi-level marketing company that stopped calling itself

Amway right around the time the Feds

started levying fines. (Here's a Dateline

report on Quixtar.)

Quain

champions the Quixtar model without once mentioning the company by

name, but he once wrote a book called The

Quixtar Price is Right

-- a volume conspicuously

absent from his Pro-Sumer Power! bio.

Think of it this way: The Quixtar Price is Right is

his Dianetics;

Pro-Sumer Power is his

Battlefield

Earth. It's on the reading

lists, it's given

out by recruiters, and it's reprehensibly stupid, but it can

almost pass as secular.

Also,

your Crap archivist encourages you to click

here, on WFMU's fantastic 365 Project, to hear Pat Boone shill for Amway.

Highlight:

If you

drag your cursor over the "Products" tab of Dr. Quain's Web site,

a drop-down menu offers a link to a book tiled Overcoming

Time Proverty.

Proverty? Is

that a pro-sumeresque combination of the words producer and

poverty? Could there be a

better formulation to describe the poor saps who have wasted their

time and savings on Quixtar based on the advice of shills like

Dr. Quain?

Unfortunately, it

turned out to be a mere type-o. A type-o that tells us nothing.

Unless ... you

THINK DIFFERENT!

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Comments (4)

Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

You say knowledge is power, but being stupid will keep you broke. Wealth is a state of mind, and as far as Prosuming, it's made me never have to be controlled by the dollar bill again. You have nothing to relate this to since you've never truly done what I and many, many other entrepreneurs have done. And anyone can quit. That doesn't take any mental fortitude.
I think your �wise� summaries of crap is crap. You can't argue my testimony. Enjoy 40 more years.

report   
Posted by Diamond Daniel on January 26, 2010 at 8:23 AM

Had I spent my time listening to Pat Boone instead of selling Amway, I might still own a car.

report   
Posted by Orphan Eagle on June 16, 2009 at 10:05 AM

L. Ron Hubbard believed we are all producers of funds and consumers of nonsense, so the analogy continues.

report   
Posted by jjskck on June 16, 2009 at 7:53 AM

Why, if these e-commerce trends continue, we'll all be kajillionaires!

report   
Posted by hecuba on June 16, 2009 at 6:17 AM
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

Most Popular Stories

Slideshows

All contents ©2012 Kansas City Pitch LLC
All rights reserved. No part of this service may be reproduced in any form without the express written permission of Kansas City Pitch LLC,
except that an individual may download and/or forward articles via email to a reasonable number of recipients for personal, non-commercial purposes.
Website powered by Foundation