Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Stop getting excited about the New York Islanders

Posted by Ben Palosaari on Wed, Aug 3, 2011 at 12:15 PM

click to enlarge The Islanders aren't moving here. It's not happening. Stop getting excited.
  • The Islanders aren't moving here. It's not happening. Stop getting excited.

OMG. Did you hear? Voters in New York's Nassau County voted down a proposed $400 million bonding deal to build the NHL's New York Islanders a shiny new arena. And, as happens every time a hockey team gets a little disgruntled, Kansas City's grand municipal circle-jerk begins. We can get them this time! We're a desirable market for the NHL! What's a pretty market? We're a pretty market! Yes, we are! 

Media outlets both local and national are now speculating about the chances that the Islanders could soon call Sprint Center home, and it's already reaching a ridiculous level. Just stop it, everybody. It's not going to happen. For once, let's handle this speculation with grace and not go through the delusional song and dance of pretending Gary Bettman lies awake at night dreaming up ways to move a team here. He doesn't. Let's get over it.



Here's a handy guide to stop you from getting your hopes up. Hang it on your fridge in case you find yourself thinking up team names or doodling jersey designs. 

  • AEG's complete lack of desire to help the city land an anchor tenant.

  • The Sprint Center is a major success each year with a team hogging up 41 dates each year.

  • Distant owners have shown in the past that they're not keen on the idea of flying to Kansas City to see their team play.

  • Mayor Sly James is being oddly fussy about what teams he wants for Sprint Center. He recently said, "If it's the [Los Angeles] Lakers, let's do the deal. You'll know you'll fill it up. ... I know we don't want an expansion team [hockey or basketball]. If the Penguins came here, ha ha, that would have been great." The Islanders aren't the Penguins or the Lakers. In a league in which more than half the teams make the playoffs each year, the Islanders have made it into the tournament once in the last five years. If James doesn't want just any old team looking for a new home, why the hell would he lobby to drag the Islanders here?

  • Islanders owner Charles Wang has said even though voters rejected the borrowing idea, he still wants to keep the team in Long Island. And even if he's lying, as team owners are known to do, he could just move the team to Brooklyn and hang on to fat New York TV revenue. It will be relatively painless for both the team and the fans.

  • There are plenty of other bigger and Canadian (cough, Quebec City, cough) cities dying for a hockey team. Hell, in Houston, another team getting some discussion, a minor league team, plays in a 17,800-seat arena. That's bigger than the Sprint Center's hockey capacity. And there's no proof that Kansas City is obsessive enough about hockey to make an NHL team successful. Sure, the Mavericks averaged 5,406 fans in their 6,000-seat arena last year over 33 games. That's impressive, but it's not 17,000 showing up to 41 dates a year for a team that is a long way from contending.

There's probably nobody who wants an NHL team to move to Kansas City more than I do. I'm pathetic enough to send the league a small fortune each year for the ability to watch Minnesota Wild games on my computer. But history and logic tell us that it's not worth giving ourselves an ulcer over the Islanders right now.

After serving for so many years as the town that other teams flirt with until they get new arenas built, it's time we play it cool and wait for a real opportunity to come around, if it ever happens.

Follow The Pitch on Facebook and on Twitter @pitchplog & @KCPitchBen.

Tags: ,

Comments (3)

Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

Sprint Center doing well? An article I read awhile back begs to differ.

http://www.fieldofschemes.com/...

"Only one problem with that description: It bears no resemblance to reality. As both I and my own corporate colleagues at The Pitch explained two years ago, the Sprint Center turns an operating profit for Kansas City — but that's only if you don't count the city's annual $13.8 million in construction bond payments. And that money is all coming from hotel and car-rental taxes — which only counts as "not raising taxes for residents" if you think that people only ever rent cars while on vacation." Neil deMause

81 days of rental may help, but will the market bear it?

report   
Posted by Old School4 on 08/04/2011 at 6:10 AM

As far as the Islanders actually moving here, I would have to agree that it's not going to happen. However, the Islanders do have some good, young talent.

*Out of their five players who scored at least 20 goals last year, all of them were 27 years old or younger. three of them were under 25, and one was just 20 years old.

*Out of their 7 players with 20 or more assists, all were 27 years old or younger (again), four were under 25 years old, and two were 20 years old.
*Their top three defensemen in ice time per game were 24, 26, and 20 years old.

*The three forwards with 200+ shots on the team were all 27 or younger, one being 20 years old.

*Their top goal scorer in the minors is only 23. He is also their top assist and point earner.

*They had 4 more picks in the top 62 picks of this year's entry draft.

report   
Posted by Ben Cerutti on 08/04/2011 at 5:32 AM

Some thoughts on your points... 

It's possible that AEG has no interesting in putting a team here because of your second point, the success of Sprint Center without a major tenant. 

But would a distant owner fly here...  you mean like the Dallas based Hunt family, or the Arkansas based David Glass? 

Sly James shouldn't be taken seriously about what team moves here, and if he went against the idea of an expansion team here in KC, he would be an idiot, and the Lakers aren't leaving LA. 

Yes Wang could move the team to Brooklyn, providing he gets the deal he wants on revenue, but he wont' be the primary tenant, and that could go against him financially. 

As far as bigger markets, there's problems with every market left...  be it Quebec City with no arena (and much smaller than KC) or other towns with inadequate arenas or other cities with no established buyers. 

Looks to me like this is the glass is 1/2 empty approach.  There no guarantee the Islanders move here, and no one should chomp at the bit expecting it, but then it's no guarantee they wouldn't move here either. 

report   
Posted by Dave on 08/03/2011 at 1:51 PM
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-3 of 3

Add a comment

Latest in Plog

Most Popular Stories

Slideshows

All contents ©2012 Kansas City Pitch LLC
All rights reserved. No part of this service may be reproduced in any form without the express written permission of Kansas City Pitch LLC,
except that an individual may download and/or forward articles via email to a reasonable number of recipients for personal, non-commercial purposes.

All contents © 2012 SouthComm, Inc. 210 12th Ave S. Ste. 100, Nashville, TN 37203. (615) 244-7989.
All rights reserved. No part of this service may be reproduced in any form without the express written permission of SouthComm, Inc.
except that an individual may download and/or forward articles via email to a reasonable number of recipients for personal, non-commercial purposes.
Website powered by Foundation